Skip to main content
You have permission to edit this article.
Renewable energy spurs some questions

Renewable energy spurs some questions

  • 0
Solar Farm in Axton

Leatherwood Solar, a solar energy generation facility on Mountain Valley Road in Axton, has been supplying Appalachian Power with energy since August. It is capable of powering up to 3,600 homes, according to an Appalachian Power press release.

Proponents of replacing fossil fuels and nuclear energy with clean renewable energy are hitting some stiff headwinds, and it isn’t from the soon-to-be extinct coal companies, major utilities or Big Oil. As a recent article in Forbes points out, the stiffest opposition to installing wind turbines and industrial-size solar farms is coming from the people in rural areas who will have to live next to them.

Since 2015, “317 local communities or government entities from Maine to Hawaii … have rejected or restricted wind projects in the U.S.” That—and the “growing hostility” to Big Solar—“are proof that land-use conflicts are the binding constraint on the expansion of renewable energy development in the U.S,” writes Robert Bryce, author of “Not in Our Backyard.”

“Land use battles are occurring in states with some of America’s most ambitious renewable energy goals,” such as California, Connecticut, New York, Pennsylvania and Vermont, Bryce points out.

The backlash is happening in Virginia as well. In May, Maroon Solar’s proposed 149-megawatt, $200 billion solar farm on agriculturally-zoned land in Culpeper County was rejected by both the county’s Planning Commission and Board of Supervisors due to intense citizen opposition led by Citizens for Responsible Solar. That same month, Fauquier County’s Board of Supervisors nixed a plan to build a five-megawatt solar farm on 40 acres along U.S. 17.

Local opposition is largely based on the fact that these large renewable energy projects cause noise, impact health, reduce property values, kill wildlife, and despoil rural viewsheds. But rural residents are also righty concerned about what will happen to used wind turbine blades and solar panels when their usefulness is over.

“According to our research, cumulative waste productions will rise far sooner and more sharply than most analysts project,” stated a recent article in the Harvard Business Review. “We see the volume of [solar] waste surpassing that of new installations by the year 2031. By 2035, discarded panels would outweigh new units sold by 2.56 times.” And most of the blades from decommissioned wind turbines are currently being sawed up and dumped in local landfills.

Rural communities are seeing thousands of acres of arable land being converted to energy production. An industrial-sized solar farm, which produces intermittent energy, requires 450 times more land than a nuclear plant, which runs 24/7. And wind turbines take up to 700 times more land than a natural gas well to produce the same amount of electricity. If more rural communities say no to these projects, will government authorities use their eminent domain power to seize their land?

People living in urban areas don’t have to worry that mountains of industrial waste from these facilities will just be abandoned in their communities. Rural residents do.

For example, in Spotsylvania County, sPower refused to post a cash bond or irrevocable letter of credit to protect county taxpayers from the cost of disposing of 1.8 million solar panels containing cadmium telluride and other toxic materials at the end of its solar farm’s useful life. Who’s going to pay for the clean-up if the LLC that built the solar facility is not around in 30 years?

That’s why proponents of renewable energy—which includes every member of the Virginia General Assembly who voted for a bill last year requiring Virginia utilities to transition to 100 percent renewables by 2050—should give voters some answers to these pressing questions.

— Fredericksburg Free-Lance Star

Catch the latest in Opinion

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Most Popular

Coal miner Betsy Mallum and the family doctor who delivered her, Sam Finnix, are not real people. But the harrowing things we see them endure on our television screens really did happen to all too many people in Southwest Virginia.

 If you think this column is going to be complaining about being squeezed into a crowded airplane, though, you’re wrong. That theme is so 2017. Airlines have found something even worse than that – the ticketing process.

The violent 2017 “Unite the Right” rally in Charlottesville was a sickening and awful ordeal that no community should have to endure. The sight of neo-Nazis and white supremacists marching at the University of Virginia and clashing in the streets with counterprotesters won’t soon fade from memory. While no amount of money can bring back Heather Heyer, the 32-year-old woman killed that day, or ...

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


Breaking News

News Alert